The Use and Abuse of Mental Health Laws

Wednesday, 9 July 2025: 13:00-14:45
Location: FSE020 (Faculty of Education Sciences (FSE))
RC49 Mental Health and Illness (host committee)

Language: English

Mental health laws have a variety of functions. They may be used to control and monitor people with mental health problems. They may also grant individuals rights and protections. Such laws typically give mental health professionals powers and duties. Recent debates have focussed on whose definitions of mental disorder get accepted and whether such laws offer just outcomes for those with mental health problems.

This session invites papers that examine mental health law at either a theoretical or empirical level. The session invites submissions that focus on issues of power and justice. Papers might analyse the emphasis given within mental health law to areas such as risks, rights or treatments. They might also focus on trends or patterns of legal decision-making either within or across countries. Submissions focussing on the way way in which legal decisions are experienced by different parties will also be welcomed.

Session Organizer:
Jeremy DIXON, Cardiff University, United Kingdom
Chair:
Kevin STONE, University of Warwick, United Kingdom
Oral Presentations
‘I Don’t Think There’s Many Black African Caribbean Men That Talk Positively about Mental Health Services’ : Mental Health Professionals’ Perspectives on Distrust Amongst Black Men Detained in Psychiatric Hospitals
Jeremy DIXON, Cardiff University, United Kingdom; Caroline LEAH, Manchester Metropolitan University, United Kingdom; Alina HAINES-DELMONT, Manchester Metropolitan University, United Kingdom; Elaine CRAIG, Manchester Metropolitan University, United Kingdom
Navigating Power and Care: A Sociological Analysis of Mental Health Act 1983 Use for People with Dementia
Chao FANG, United Kingdom; Jeremy DIXON, Cardiff University, United Kingdom; Judy LAING, University of Bristol, United Kingdom; Demi PATSIOS, Bristol University, United Kingdom
The Questionable Legitimacy of Mental Health Laws
Dirk RICHTER, Bern University of Applied Sciences, Switzerland