Exploring the Role of Civil Society in Contentious Politics: The Bystanders and Implicated Subjects

Monday, 7 July 2025: 13:00-14:45
Location: SJES027 (Faculty of Legal, Economic, and Social Sciences (JES))
RC48 Social Movements, Collective Actions and Social Change (host committee)

Language: English and Spanish

Bystanders are those who lived through a violent or repressive period, but who were neither perpetrators nor victims of crimes. Michael Rothberg (2019) expands this conceptualization to include the concept of ‘implicated subject,’ as an umbrella term beyond the binary of victim/perpetrator or the triad perpetrator-victim-bystander. The term refers to people who 'occupy positions aligned with power and privilege... contribute to, inhabit, inherit, or benefit from regimes of domination, but do not originate or control such regimes.'

One of the normative assumptions of Transitional Justice is that truth promotes solidarity between victims and the rest of civil society while simultaneously questioning the role of bystanders/implicated subjects. For this to be possible, it is necessary for bystanders/implicated subjects to participate in the processes that address the legacy of violence and conflict. This session focuses on examining the different roles, discourses, and emotions associated with bystanders/implicated subjects in transitional and post-conflict societies, paying attention to the factors that affect, facilitate, or complicate the involvement of bystanders/implicated subjects in processes of social transformation and collective action.

Session Organizer:
Sandra RIOS OYOLA, PhD, University College Roosevelt, Netherlands
Chair:
Sandra RIOS OYOLA, PhD, University College Roosevelt, Netherlands
Oral Presentations
Non-Participants and Symbolic Reparation in Colombia
Sandra RIOS OYOLA, PhD, University College Roosevelt, Netherlands
Building a Counter Hegemonic Memory of Victims of State Police Racism in France
Orian LEMPEREUR-CASTELLI LEMPEREUR-CASTELLI, PSL - EHESS, France
Building up a National Public Policy on Mental-Health Reparations for Victims of State Violence in Brazil
Renata COSTA-MOURA, Universidade Federal Fluminense, Brazil; Fiammetta BONFIGLI, University of Vienna, Austria
Distributed Papers